Bishops not showing their faces - guilty? |
So
Francis says that Catholic bishops guilty of negligence in child abuse cases
can now be dismissed from office. Is it
a coincidence that Frances made this announcement just two weeks after he came
under fire for meeting French Cardinal Philippe Barbarin, Archbishop of Lyon, accused
of covering up for a pedophile priest in a scandal that has shaken France’s
Catholic Church? Francis said then it would be “nonsensical and imprudent” to
seek Barbarin’s resignation.
French
law officials are deciding whether to pursue charges against Barbarin for his
handling of the allegations against Bernard Preynat, a priest in his diocese
who has been charged with sex abuse. Police raided the offices of a clerical
judicial adviser to the Lyon diocese and Barbarin will be questioned by police
shortly, according to the French press. Good for the French police – let’s hope
other countries follow their lead.
David
Clohessy, director of SNAP, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests is, with good cause, very skeptical about this “new” plan working. In the case of the abuse of minors, “Popes and bishops have long had the power,
but not the will, to oust those who protect predators and endanger kids. They
refuse to do this, and the consequences are devastating,” Clohessy said. “When
it’s advantageous to move quickly, Catholic officials move quickly. When they
want to move slowly, or not at all, they set up commissions and ‘processes’ and
the like.”
The
bishops, according to Francis, can be sacked for “serious reasons.” But who is deciding what is serious? We’ve
seen for 2000 years that self-policing by the church hierarchy changes nothing
when it comes to justice for child sex abuse victims.
How
can Francis say, in the face of worldwide child sexual abuse by his church
which has mostly gone unpunished that:
“The
Church, like a loving mother, loves all her children, but treats and protects
with special affection the smallest and most helpless.” My brother and I were not protected from the
priest who raped us and the nuns who beat us – so what is he talking about? Maybe he believes his own lies.
The
Pope’s tribunal set up to discipline bishops did nothing for a year. Now Francis has a “college of legal experts”
— cardinals and bishops —to assist him in reaching a decision in a particular
case. Sounds like more stone-walling to me: Roman Catholic bishops who have
failed to properly handle sex abuse cases will be investigated by four Vatican
offices - of course decisions will have
to wait until all four offices are done.
Canon
(church) law already provides for the removal of bishops “for serious causes,” which
the pope has acknowledged. So how come
no bishops were removed? We are back to
the “serious” acts that Francis and his minions will define. So far covering up
child rape has not been serious enough to result in bishop dismissal.
Let’s
see how soon Pope Francis’ “new” plan will produce action that will make a
difference in the lives of those of us abused by the catholic church. Let’s check back a year from now and see if
this new committee did anything besides protect the reputation of the church
and use parishioners’ money to defend criminal bishops and priests.
No comments:
Post a Comment